Computer Port IT Solutions

Asia Pacific Community Champions of OpenNebula | Proxmox Silver Partner

Proxmox vs VMware: Complete Comparison Dashboard
Make informed decisions with comprehensive analysis and ROI calculations

Platform Overview

🟠 Proxmox VE

Open-source virtualization platform combining KVM hypervisor and LXC containers. Enterprise features with flexible licensing and strong community support.

Open Source Cost-Effective

🔵 VMware vSphere

Industry-leading enterprise virtualization platform with comprehensive features, extensive ecosystem, and proven reliability at scale.

Enterprise Premium

Key Differences

Feature Proxmox VE VMware vSphere
Licensing Model Annual subscription per socket Perpetual license per socket + annual support
Hypervisor KVM (Linux-based) ESXi (proprietary)
Container Support Native LXC containers Limited (via 3rd party)
Management Interface Web-based GUI included vCenter (separate license)
Storage ZFS, Ceph, LVM, NFS, iSCSI VMFS, vSAN, NFS, iSCSI
High Availability Included in all tiers Requires specific licenses

Performance Metrics

Proxmox CPU Overhead
2-5%
Near-native performance
VMware CPU Overhead
3-7%
Excellent optimization
Memory Efficiency
Similar
Both use advanced techniques
Storage I/O
Comparable
Workload dependent

Performance Comparison

Metric Proxmox VE VMware vSphere Notes
VM Density High (efficient KVM) High (optimized ESXi) Both support high consolidation ratios
Network Throughput 10+ Gbps (SR-IOV support) 10+ Gbps (advanced features) Hardware dependent
Boot Time Fast (minimal overhead) Fast (optimized) Similar performance
Snapshot Performance Excellent (native LVM/ZFS) Excellent (VMFS) Technology dependent

Feature Comparison

Feature Proxmox VE VMware vSphere
Live Migration ✅ Included ✅ Included (vMotion)
High Availability ✅ All subscription tiers ✅ Higher editions only
Backup & Replication ✅ Built-in (Proxmox Backup) ✅ Requires add-ons
Software-Defined Storage ✅ Ceph integration ✅ vSAN (separate license)
API Access ✅ RESTful API ✅ Comprehensive API
Clustering ✅ Up to 32 nodes ✅ Up to 96 hosts
Container Support ✅ Native LXC ❌ Limited
ZFS Support ✅ Native ❌ Not supported
Distributed Switch ✅ Open vSwitch ✅ vDS (higher editions)

Licensing Models

Proxmox VE Licensing

Community Edition: Free, full features, no support (€115/year for repo access)

Basic: €355/year per socket - Email support, updates

Standard: €530/year per socket - Business hours phone support

Premium: €1,060/year per socket - 24/7 support, 2-hour response

VMware vSphere Licensing

Perpetual Model (Per-Socket):

Standard: $995 license (one-time) + $273/year support per CPU

Enterprise Plus: $3,495 license (one-time) + $956/year support per CPU

VCF: $5,500 license (one-time) + $1,650/year support per CPU

Note: Prices in USD per physical CPU socket. vCenter sold separately.

Migration Planning

Assessment Phase

• Inventory all VMs and workloads

• Document dependencies

• Evaluate storage requirements

• Network architecture review

• Licensing audit

Planning Phase

• Define migration strategy

• Create testing environment

• Develop rollback procedures

• Schedule maintenance windows

• Train IT staff

Execution Phase

• Pilot migration (non-critical VMs)

• Validate functionality

• Phased production migration

• Monitor performance

• Documentation updates

Migration Tools & Methods

Method Description Complexity
P2V Conversion Physical to Virtual migration Medium
V2V Migration VMware to Proxmox conversion using qemu-img Medium
Storage Migration Copy/convert VM disks between platforms Low
Application Rebuild Deploy fresh VMs, migrate application data High

Real-World Case Studies

Manufacturing Company - 500 Employee Organization

Challenge: High VMware licensing costs with 50 VMs across 10 hosts

Solution: Migrated to Proxmox VE with Premium support

Results:

  • 70% reduction in annual virtualization costs
  • Maintained 99.9% uptime SLA
  • Successfully migrated in 6-week timeframe
  • Added Ceph storage for high availability

Financial Services Firm - Enterprise Deployment

Challenge: Budget constraints with expanding virtualization needs

Solution: Hybrid approach - retained VMware for critical systems, Proxmox for development

Results:

  • 40% cost savings on non-production infrastructure
  • Maintained compliance requirements
  • Improved development environment flexibility
  • Staff trained on both platforms

Healthcare Provider - Multi-Site Deployment

Challenge: Budget constraints with strict uptime requirements

Solution: Full Proxmox deployment across 5 locations with 25 hosts

Results:

  • $200,000+ annual savings vs VMware
  • Achieved 99.95% uptime
  • Implemented disaster recovery with Proxmox Backup Server
  • Reduced management complexity

ROI Calculator

Configuration Parameters

Proxmox Total Cost
$0
Over 5 years
VMware Total Cost
$0
Over 5 years
Total Savings
$0
0% reduction
ROI Period
-
Payback time

Cost Comparison Over Time

Detailed Cost Breakdown

Item Proxmox VMware